OpenPolitics.ca : sovereignty

sovereignty

Sovereignty is one of the most basic but perhaps most contested concepts in politics. A sovereign (state or person) is the unsurpassed ruler of a territory. Fundamentally the concept of sovereignty relates to property rights. Except in certain rare circumstances - like Antarctica? - every square inch of terrain on earth is claimed to belong to at least one sovereign government. Except perhaps for the radical fringe of the green movement? few seem to question the right (based in many religious traditions) that the human governments are the defacto "owners" of all the land and everything on it, including the people, are at best, leaseholders. Perhaps surprisingly there is almost no precedent for shared sovereignty over any piece of land, although various proposals for sovereignty association? have been debated in Canada.

sovereignty and international relations

Membership in the United Nations is reserved only for nations who have recognized sovereignty. You can't be a nation unless you own real estate. This stipulation which leads to a fair number of warfare?. Nations under occupation (like Palestine) or separatist? movements who have not been fully recognized (like Taiwan).

sovereignty and the social contract

Sovereignty as ownership is an ancient concept, and only recently (very recently in some places) has there been any formalization of limits to the internal powers of a sovereign. Historically individuals have "belonged" to the state and the interests of the sovereign have always trumped any individual rights, even to life. Only in the later twentieth century was the right of the state to kill its citizens questioned. The Magna Carta? is perhaps the earliest legal precedent limiting the power of the sovereign. The UN declaration of Human Rights? is the first legal document that recognized rights to individuals universally.

In theory a democracy sovereignty rests with the population via the constitution, though in practice the government establishes the laws, and enforces them.

related issues

Freedoms, democracy, government, rights, self determination?.

positions

[+] Sovereignty is Outdated

That humans should be governed purely on the basis of geography is a concept which does not fit the political and economic realities of the post millennial era. Concepts of sovereignty where individuals are solely "owned" by the state are at odds with the progress of human rights, basic freedoms?, and arguably, economic and social advancement.

Sovereignty voids the social contract. The fundamental premise of the social contract is that individuals pledge allegiance to a government in return for certain benefits and protections. However the concept of sovereignty removes this choice - humans are governed, taxed, and administered whether they agree to the contract or not. That their can be only one sovereign in a given territory creates the necessity for civil war? or terrorism if a group has a dispute with the existing government.
Sovereignty is monopolistic. Governments are not exempt from the economic truism that competition drives efficiency, economic development and social well being. By their monopolistic nature governments are backward, inefficient, wasteful and almost invariably corrupted, because there exists no legitimate alternative, inefficiency and corruption can become permanent features of government.
Sovereignty reinforces inequality. By its nature sovereign governments have "insider" and "outsider" cultures, and invariably there are demographic groups (economic, ethnic, geographic) that are excluded from power, and oppressed by the ruling "insiders".
Alternatives are possible. It is not inevitable that all territory must belong to one (and only one) sovereign state. International commerce thrives without requiring an overarching legal system. Legal systems based on common law can exist with or without a state. While the instantaneous elimination of all existing forms of government would obviously be met with utter chaos, it is hard to find an example of a service that could not be organized without the coercion of a government.
Tribe is necessary, sovereignty is not.

[+] (title of position)

sources and resources

List sources cited and external links.

Use decriptive links, like this:

[http:/anysite.ca/full_url|document title] - Author or Agency name

Wiki evolution

- Mattias Beermann