social justice
Social Justice is an ideal which, in most definitions has two basic assumptions:
- equality is moral: that the happiness of one person cannot be considered more important than any another, see: egalitarian?
- society exists: that there are basic, "inalienable" or "inherent" rights in society which belong to all, by the agreement of all, belong to all, and these need to be protected enforced or provided by the state. see: social contract
Thus it is immoral for society to allow certain people or groups to suffer in lack of certain basic rights, and that if private enterprise or individual charity can't satisfy these rights, that the government must do something about it.
Different definitions of social justice differ mainly in which rights are considered to be "inalienable" and in reality, the notion of what rights should be guaranteed is a evolving, generally with
progressive individuals adding more rights to the list of what is essential, and
conservatives arguing that the current set is sufficient or already goes to far.
[+] a liberal position on social justice
- supports the equality of opportunity?, so that the state should intervene so that everyone has a chance to succeed in life, and supports public education as an example.
- generally does not support income? support programs - since everyone has a chance, there should be no free lunch.
[+] a socialist position on social justice.
- favors a minimal equality of result?, such as a minimum income? or a maximum income?.
- enacts cradle to grave? social programs such as medicare?.
- favors universal programs?
[+] a libertarian position on social justice
- the social contract only includes the rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. and usually also the right of owning property?.
- the state should only enforce negative rights?, such that there are things you cannot do, and if you do you will be punished.
- advocates charity? alone, so that the social safety net should not be funded by the government.
[+] a feminist? position on social justice.
[+] an environmentalist? position on social justice.
Issues related to social justice differ from country to country,
[+] Aspects of Social Justice
[+] Gender equity
Gender equity is one of the key principles of the Green Party. "Sexism," "mysogyny," and "patriarchy" are some of the many names that have been given to that process which favours the masculine over the feminine. This often manifests itself in privileges being granted to men while denied to women, but is also apparent in the persistence of atrocities like
child poverty and
violence against women in our society,
[+] Global Justice
Global justice is a term for social justice as it is applied to people who lie beyond our traditional circle of consideration. Do people who don't live in Canada have moral standing in Green Party policies? Should they? To what extent should their interests be considered in our policies?
The nation of your birth is a historical accident: Canadians are no more deserving of social justice, ecological integrity, non-violence, etc, than anyone else. Accordingly,
global justice is part and parcel of social justice.
[+] Economic injustice
Economic injustice is the result of vast disparities in wealth, where many are denied access to full participation in the community.
[+] Environmental Justice
The environmental justice
? movement addresses the merging of social justice and environmental interests, assuming that '''people' are an integral part of what should be understood as the 'environment.'"
Dana Alston, director of the environment program at the Public Welfare Foundation, argues that
environmental justice must be seen through an overall network of social, racial and economic justice, and the environment is just one piece in a whole linkage ... It calls for a total redefinition of terms and language to describe the conditions that people are facing and to come up with solutions.
both quotes from Di Chiro, G. "Environmental Justice from the Grassroots: Reflections on History, Gender, and Expertise." In: Daniel Faber (ed.), The Struggle for Ecological Democracy: Environmental Justice Movements in the United States. New York : Guilford. pp. 104-136, 1998.
[+] Some definitions
Mc-Graw Hill Online Learning Centre
Equitable access to resources and the benefits derived from them; a system that recognizes inalienable rights and adheres to what is fair, honest, and moral.
Definition from
Wikipedia
:
Social justice, sometimes called civil justice, is a concept largely based on various social contract theories. Most variations on the concept hold that as governments are instituted among populations for the benefit of members of those populations, those governments which fail to see to the welfare of their citizens are failing to uphold their part in the social contract and are, therefore, unjust. The concept usually includes, but is not limited to, upholding human rights; many variants also contain some statements concerning more equitable distributions of wealth and resources.
The term "social justice" is generally so phrased in order to distinguish this particular concept from concepts of justice in law — some of which, according to their critics, are decidedly unjust in a social sense — and from concepts of justice as embedded in systems of morality which may differ between cultures.
Social justice refers to the overall fairness of a society in its divisions of rewards and burdens.
Some Suggested Models for Social Justice
Social justice can be a slippery idea to get one's head around. Previous attempts on my part have ended up with me longing for a more manageable task, herding ferrets, or something.
This is how some others have modelled it. Please add other examples.
Ontario Coalition for Social Justice
- expanding the quality, accessibility and universality of health care, education and social welfare programmes
- promoting anti-racism
- advocating economic policies that protect the rights of workers and lead to fair employment with compensation at a liveable wage
- protecting the programmes and services that ensure our quality of life in Ontario
Centre for Social Justice
- Democracy and Corporate Power
- Inequality - race, gender, economic, health
- Peace and Justice
Citizens for Public Justice
- Socioeconomic issues
- Faith and public life
- Refugees
- Aboriginal issues
Green Party of the U.S.
- Civil Rights and Equal Rights
- Environmental Justice
- Economic Justice/Social Safety Net
- Welfare: A commitment to ending poverty
- Education and the Arts
- Health Care
- Labour
- Criminal Justice
- Population
- Free Speech and Media Reform
- Immigration/Emigration
- Housing and Homelessness
Injustice thrives on invisibility. When people's interests are not represented, they are quickly forgotten. Amartya Sen reminds us that even the most 'efficient' economy (which, after a Green tax shift, would also be environmentally efficient) doesn't mean much for social welfare.
A person who starts off ill-endowed may stay poor and deprived even after the transactions, and if {efficiency} is all that competition offers, the propertyless person may be forgiven for not regarding this achievement as a "big deal."
from Sen, A. 1977. "Rational Fools: A Critique of the Behavioural Foundations of Economic Theory." Philosophy and Public Affairs 6(4): 317-344